What sinks O-1 petitions. 33 appeal decisions, read.
We read every O-1 decision the Administrative Appeals Office published with a date from January 2025 to September 2026. Thirty-one of the 33 appeals were dismissed. Here is what went wrong, and what founders can do differently.
Research by Racine Staub, attorney. Published .
Most never reached three of eight.
An O-1A needs evidence meeting at least three of eight criteria, or one major international award, before USCIS weighs the record as a whole. In 15 of the 17 O-1A decisions, the petition failed at that first step. Most of the arts and film cases failed at their own version of it.
The reasons repeat. Evidence that shows a person is good at their job, such as licenses, certifications, funding or local recognition, was treated as something less than the national or international acclaim the criteria describe. And evidence that might have counted was often filed without the explanation that would have made it count.
The AAO rarely disagreed with the first decision. In two cases it sent the petition back to USCIS for a new look; it dismissed the other 31.
What the decisions keep saying.
- Funding is not an awardTwo chief technology officers of AI startups relied on venture and seed funding as "prizes or awards." The AAO found no showing that funding is recognized as an award for excellence. Dec 11, 2025; May 5, 2025.
- An accelerator is not an exclusive membershipA "founders" program was not shown to admit people for outstanding achievements judged by recognized experts. May 5, 2025.
- Press has to be about you, in a publication that countsAn article listing the startups in a cohort was not about the beneficiary. Another petitioner never showed that a magazine was a professional or major publication. May 5, 2025; Apr 27, 2026.
- Citations need contextAltmetric statistics without explanation, and publications or presentations without proof of their impact, did not show contributions of major significance. Dec 11, 2025; Apr 2, 2026.
- Credentials are not achievementsA trade certification, coaching licenses and a training qualification were each found to show competence, not outstanding achievement. Sep 15, 2026; Feb 25, 2025; Mar 17, 2026.
- Other people's awards do not countPrizes won by a coach's students were not awards to the coach. Nov 5, 2025.
- Every exhibit needs a jobDocuments filed without saying which criterion they prove, screenshots without sources, and reference letters with little detail all failed. Apr 29, 2026; Feb 25, 2025; Jun 17, 2026.
- The basics still sink casesOne petition failed partly for missing the required consultation from a peer group. Another was filed as an O-1A for an occupation the petitioner never showed fits the O-1A fields. May 21, 2025; May 22, 2025.
Build the record the criteria ask for.
- Build judging earlyJudge startup competitions, hackathons or accelerator demo days, or review for journals and conferences in your field, and keep the invitations. What counts as judging.
- Earn press about youCoverage that names and discusses you, in outlets you can show are major or professional publications, not just your company's launch.
- Prove your role was criticalShow what the company achieved because of you, and why the company itself is distinguished: funding, customers, rankings, coverage.
- Explain impact in numbersUsers, revenue, adoption, citations, and what they mean in your field. A metric without context is not evidence.
- Price your compensationSalary plus the value of your equity, compared with market data for your role and location.
- Write to the criteriaOrganize the petition criterion by criterion, and say exactly what each exhibit proves.
All 17, one line each.
The full dataset, including the 16 O-1B arts and film decisions, is in the CSV.
| Decided | Occupation | Outcome | Main issue | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2026-09-23 | Export sales director | Dismissed | Did not meet three criteria; published material claim rejected | |
| 2026-09-15 | Paintless dent repair specialist | Dismissed | Did not meet three criteria; membership and judging claims rejected (a trade certification is not an outstanding-achievement membership) | |
| 2026-08-25 | General manager | Dismissed | Did not meet three criteria; awards not shown to be nationally or internationally recognized | |
| 2026-06-17 | Robotics and welding specialist | Dismissed | Met none of the claimed criteria; reference letters too general | |
| 2026-04-27 | Business (embedded software and hardware robotics) | Dismissed | Met none of eight criteria; unsubstantiated claim that a magazine was a professional publication | |
| 2026-04-02 | Badminton coach | Decision withdrawn | AAO found evidence appeared to satisfy a third criterion; returned to USCIS | |
| 2026-04-02 | Global engagement programs coordinator | Dismissed | Did not meet three criteria; publications and presentations without proof of major significance | |
| 2026-03-24 | Senior scientist | Dismissed | Did not meet three criteria; conference award and judging claims rejected | |
| 2026-03-17 | Equestrian eventing trainer | Dismissed | Met none of four claimed criteria; training qualification not an outstanding achievement | |
| 2025-12-11 | Chief technology officer | Dismissed | Did not meet three criteria; venture funding is not a prize or award; citation metrics without context did not show major significance | |
| 2025-11-05 | Fencing master | Dismissed | Did not meet three criteria; awards won by others (students) do not count for the beneficiary | |
| 2025-05-22 | Mixologist | Dismissed | Filed as O-1A; the petitioner did not show the occupation fits the O-1A fields (sciences, education, business or athletics) | |
| 2025-05-21 | Archaeologist | Dismissed | Consultation requirement not satisfied; initial criteria not met | |
| 2025-05-13 | Technology entrepreneur | Dismissed | Met none of eight criteria | |
| 2025-05-05 | Chief technology officer | Dismissed | Did not meet three criteria; seed and venture funding are not awards; accelerator founder program not an outstanding-achievement membership; cohort article not about the beneficiary | |
| 2025-02-25 | Goalkeeper program director | Dismissed | Did not meet three criteria; coaching licenses and unsourced screenshots did not qualify | |
| 2025-02-20 | Financial vice president | Dismissed | Did not meet three criteria; unsupported claim that criteria did not apply (comparable evidence) |
Method: all non-precedent decisions listed under Form I-129, Extraordinary Ability (O), in the AAO database at uscis.gov, with decision dates from January 1, 2025 to September 30, 2026, as of November 19, 2026. Each decision was read in full and classified by Racine Staub Law. Appeals come only from denied petitions, so this is not an approval rate. Dataset license: CC BY 4.0.
Straight answers.
What is the AAO?
The Administrative Appeals Office is the part of USCIS that hears appeals from denied petitions, including O-1 petitions. Most of its decisions are non-precedent: they decide only the case in front of them, but they show how USCIS reads the criteria.
Does this mean most O-1A petitions are denied?
No. These are appeals from petitions that had already been denied, so they are a skewed sample. They show where weak petitions fail, not how often petitions are approved.
If my O-1A is denied, should I appeal?
Sometimes. Options include an appeal to the AAO, a motion to reopen or reconsider, or a new petition with stronger evidence. Since the AAO dismissed 31 of these 33 appeals, refiling with a stronger record is often the more practical route. If you have a denial or an RFE, the response page explains how I review it.
Can I use this data?
Yes. The dataset is free to use under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 license: please credit Racine Staub Law and link to this page. The decisions themselves are public records published by USCIS.
Build the case before you file.
Start with a short intake. I'll review it, and we'll meet for a Path Session: a video consultation where we test your record against each route and agree on the strongest one, what it takes and what it costs. $450, credited to your case if you engage me within 30 days.
